Login

→

Out of a Glock 17, 21, and 22, which is better for police duty?

By Yahoo Answers
2007-10-15 15:54:51
I personally like the Glock 21, but I'm simply a fan of the .45 ACP so its easy to see why I'm drawn to it. I also like the 17 (9mm), but haven't heard much about the G22 (.40). Any input? Anyone have some info bout the G37? I believe its either .40 or .45??? ...and yes I do like Kimber's and Springfield's .45 ACP, but I'm looking for a Glock right now...
Answered By: S R
Many LE agencies have switched away from the 9mm and gone to .40 or .45. I personally own a Glock 30 (.45). It is compact and perfect for concealment when I am wearing enough to cover it. At work, everyone carries a .45. Some carry the Kimber that looks like the 1911, but I and several others carry a Glock 21SF. In my experience with shooting a Glock 17, the recoil seems to make the barrel jump up more than when shooting a .45, that seems to recoil straight back and allow me to stay on target. At least that's how it works for me. I strongly recommend a .45 for duty carry. I can see why you would be a fan of it. You may have more shots with a 9mm but that's because you will probably need them. They just don't have the stopping power of the .45. I can tell you that the Glock 21SF is one SWEET gun. You really need to get one in your hand and see how it feels. If you can't hold it, you can't shoot it, so pick up a couple different models and see how they fit your hand. The difference between the 21 and the 21SF is the 21SF has a smaller grip size and ambidextrous mag release--can come in handy for support hand shooting. I don't like the Picatinny rail system on the 21SF because it causes problems with some holsters and just plain looks ugly so be sure to specify the Glock rail. I know some people have trouble qualifying with a .45 but I really believe it is mental. Anyway, if a .45 doesn't work for you, I would go with the largest caliber you can shoot a good score with (not just qualify) because the most import thing really is being able to hit your target. As for the .40 ... I think it is just a compromise round that is bigger than a 9mm but gives you the ability to carry more rounds. I think you lose on both ends of that compromise but most people would disagree with me. Anyway, I carry my 21SF with 14 rounds (13 +1). I think that is a pretty respectable amount of firepower.
User: pendleton4068
try the 37
User: SCCA/LAPD
I would say the 9mm Berreta ( and the ak 47 )
User: kevw25
I use the Glock 22. I like the .40 because It is larger than the 9mm, which I don't think has the best stopping power in the world, and smaller than the .45 which gives me problems at the range when qualifying. Plus I have 15 chances with one mag, god forbid I ever need that many to take down a threat... It is really up to your personal preference and what your department allows.
User: S R
Many LE agencies have switched away from the 9mm and gone to .40 or .45. I personally own a Glock 30 (.45). It is compact and perfect for concealment when I am wearing enough to cover it. At work, everyone carries a .45. Some carry the Kimber that looks like the 1911, but I and several others carry a Glock 21SF. In my experience with shooting a Glock 17, the recoil seems to make the barrel jump up more than when shooting a .45, that seems to recoil straight back and allow me to stay on target. At least that's how it works for me. I strongly recommend a .45 for duty carry. I can see why you would be a fan of it. You may have more shots with a 9mm but that's because you will probably need them. They just don't have the stopping power of the .45. I can tell you that the Glock 21SF is one SWEET gun. You really need to get one in your hand and see how it feels. If you can't hold it, you can't shoot it, so pick up a couple different models and see how they fit your hand. The difference between the 21 and the 21SF is the 21SF has a smaller grip size and ambidextrous mag release--can come in handy for support hand shooting. I don't like the Picatinny rail system on the 21SF because it causes problems with some holsters and just plain looks ugly so be sure to specify the Glock rail. I know some people have trouble qualifying with a .45 but I really believe it is mental. Anyway, if a .45 doesn't work for you, I would go with the largest caliber you can shoot a good score with (not just qualify) because the most import thing really is being able to hit your target. As for the .40 ... I think it is just a compromise round that is bigger than a 9mm but gives you the ability to carry more rounds. I think you lose on both ends of that compromise but most people would disagree with me. Anyway, I carry my 21SF with 14 rounds (13 +1). I think that is a pretty respectable amount of firepower.
User: sammael_coh
Glock may be ceasing production on .45 ACP since they now have their own caliber (.45 GAP). Personally, I prefer the Glock 22. A nice mid-range caliber with excellent ammunition choices.
User: pathfinder
The Glock model 22, because the .40 S&W round imparts more energy on the target than the 9mm, or the slower moving .45ACP round.
User: Copgirl
I carry the 21.

by Yahoo Answers